The Horn

Contact Me

Receive Email Updates

The Met's New Rigoletto - Is It Ok To Tamper With An Opera ?

   The Metropolitan opera has premiered its eagerly awaited new production of Verdi's  grim but beloved masterpiece Rigoletto , and the reviews are mixed, as usual .  The controversy lies in the production , which has been much ballyhooed  since it was first announced last year . The opera is set in 16th century Mantua,Italy  in case you're not familiar with it (and you definitely should get to know it if not) , and  is the sordid and tragic tale of a handsome but  licentious Duke and his  bitter  and cynical  court Jester Rigoletto , who  is deathly afraid that  the Duke will seduce his innocent young daughter  , whom he keeps  under close watch  .  He hates the Duke, and hires a  16th century hitman to  assasinate him , but  the whole  thing goes horribly wrong , and  the poor girl is not only seduced  ,but the hitman  betrays him  ... well, I won't give the story away . 

    As is  so common today , the  director and designer of the new production  have updated the action to  around 1960 in -  Las Vegas !  The Duke is now a  popular Vegas singer, and Rigoletto is a comedian  who is part of his act .  In  the original setting , the court at Mantua is just as  corrupt, licentious and decadent as  Las Vegas ,  and there's plenty of intrigue and  lust .  The court at Mantua becomes a  gaudy Las Vegas casino .

    Anthony Tommasini , chief music critic of the New York  Times  , had some reservations about the staging , but liked it on the whole .  James Jorden   of the New York Post ,  thought it was  lame and unconvincing .  I'll reserve judgment until I see it  on  a PBS telecast .  But  the production does not appear to be nearly as outrageous  as many European stagings of operas  since about the 1980s ,  which  have been downright bizarre, even  grossly perverse , with all kinds of  gratuitous sexnudity , gratuitous violence  and absurdly arbitrary gimmicks  . 

    The acclaimed German coloratura soprano Diana Damrau, who sings Rigoletto's  beautiful but naive daughter Gilda in the Met production ,recently  starred n a Munich production of the opera  where the characters were dressed as gorillas and chimpnzees !   Last year's Bayreuth production  of Wagner's Lohengrin, which takes place in  medieval  Belgium  , has the chorus  dressed in  costumes which deliberately make them look like rats !   What on earth does this have to do with  the knights and soldiers of medieval Belgium ?  The production of Parsifal, Wagner's last opera, which takes place in  the north of medieval Spain in the realm of the   knights who guard  the Holy Grail ,  features  a prop  on stage which  is  the  decaying body of a rabbit !  Much larger than a real rabbit, of course .  But why ? 

    The famous American theater and opera director Peter Sellars has staged Mozart's "The Marriage of Figaro", which takes place in an 18th century  Spanish  palace of a nobleman , in  New York's Trump tower , and the nobleman  is  a  blllionaire  tycoon !   Sellar's production of Mozart's "Don Giovanni" , which is set in 18th century Seville , is  set in  Spanish Harlem  among  pimps  and drug dealers !   Sheesh !

     Opera directors and designers have been vying with each other to create the most  outlandish  and perverse opera productions possiible . It's De Rigeur in Europe , and it seems that any  production team which  did a  traditional production set in the actual time and place of the opera would get booed off the stage today there, especially in Germany . 

    What is the point of all of this nonsense ?  It's known as  "Regietheater" in German , or  "director's theater " .  It also goes by the  name of "Eurotrash opera ".  In recent years,  there have also been  similar updated productions of  some of the Shakespeare plays ;  not too long ago, I saw a London production of Hamlet on PBS which  transferred the action of the opera to  what looked like the near future .  It didn't bother me too much , and  the  drama came through unscathed . 

    Fortunately, the Met  has  resisted the most  outrageous  staging  and visual gimmicks , and although critics might  justifiably have some reservations about  the productions ,  they have not been  ridiculous for the most part   .  The recent new production of Donoizetti's charming  bucolic  comic opera  "L'Elisir D'Amore (the elixir of love )  , which was telecast on  PBS just two weeks ago,is entirely traditional , and put  the opera in the original  early 19th century  setting  . Even the sets looked chamringly old-fashioned  , rather like something from the 1920s or 30s . 

    But several years ago,  the New York City opera, now  unfortunately struggling to  mainstain its existence ,  set the opera in  1960s America ,  and the characters were right out of  "Laverne and Shirley " on television .  The set evoked 60s  pop culture America . 

    Ultimately, what matters is whether the production works or not , or is  just a ridiculous collection of arbitrary gimmicks .  You have to take each production today on an indivisual basis . Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't .  You can get many of these  productions on DVD . Decide for yourself . 

Posted: Jan 30 2013, 11:38 PM by the horn | with no comments
Add to Bloglines Add to Del.icio.us Add to digg Add to Facebook Add to Google Bookmarks Add to Newsvine Add to reddit Add to Stumble Upon Add to Shoutwire Add to Squidoo Add to Technorati Add to Yahoo My Web