The Horn

Contact Me

Receive Email Updates

When It Comes To Interpreting Music , Classical Musicians Have No Constitution

  Composers, music critics, musicologists ,performers and fans are forever arguing over how music should or should not be interpreted .  In many ways , this is similar to the way politicians , pundits , commentators  and  private citizens in America are forever arguing over the interpretation of the U.S. Constitution .

  In classical music , there are those who insist on  strict observance of  the composer's directions in the written music , and those who believe that musicians should be allowed considerable leeway in  realizing  those  written instructions .  In other words, the strict  observation of the founding father's "original intentions" (whatever those were), or a "living constitution".  The problem is that the written music can only tell the musician so much ; there is plenty of room for the performer to personalize the music . 

   If you look at the score of any orchestral work or opera, or  other music such as that written for the piano and chamber music etc , you will see  all manner of written instructions . Not just the notes, but  indications ,usually in Italian but not always , or how fast or slow to play a work,  the dynamics (loudness and softness ),
indications for the kind of  expressive character of the music ,  speeding up and slowing down (accelerando and
ritardando in Italian , and much more .

   In general , the older the music , the fewer the  written instructions .  For example , in the music of Bach , which comes from the first half of the 18th century, there is generally not much information about those
parameters I've just mentioned . But if you excamine the score of a symphony of Mahler, whose music was written in the late 19th and early 20th century,  there is an enormous amount of specific detail as to how to perform the music , even  paragraphs  with  special instructions .  One wag  said that "The only written instruction you don't find in a Mahler symphony is '  no smoking' !

   But there are other things that can't be  written out exactly , such as "rubato", or stolen time in Italian , or using  subtle flexibility of tempo for expressive effect .  The composer will sometimes ask for the performer or conductor to speed up or slow down , but rubato is much more subtle . 

   What's appropriate in the music of  one composer or period  may not be appropriate for  that of another composer or time .  Musicians are always talking about "the composer's intentions", but those are not necessarily written in stone, and composer do change their minds .  Sometimes performers will  add nuances not actually specified by the composer, but yet the composers approved of these anyway.

   In  other cases , performers have gone over the top and  committed the musical equivalent of painting a mustache on the Mona Lisa, and  the composers were  outraged .  Composers have often conducted or played their own music ,  and  quite a few recordings by the composers themselves have been made over the years, those this gives musicians  clear guidelines . But even they have been known to play their music differently at different times,  with faster or slower tempi, for example .

   Tempo, or the rate of speed  at which a piece is performed , is one of the most controversial issues in classical music .  If you listen to different recordings of say, any given Beethoven symphony , not all use the same rates of speed , and there is considerable  difference from one recording to another . Timings for a long symphony by Bruckner or Mahler  can differ by as much as ten minutes or so  from conductor X or Y . 

   But what tempo or tempi are the right ones for any given work ?  There are no easy answers .
Beethoven, who was very concerned about  performers getting what he felt were the right tempi for his works ,  used the then recent invention of the metronome  to give performers guidelines so that  performances   would not be either too slow or too fast .  But even he is knwon to have changed his mind . 

   Sometimes musicians have been known to  play music at perversely wrong   tempi ,  usually too slow , although  sometimes to fast .  The great German conductor Otto Klemperer (1885 - 1973 )  is known to 
have performed some works  by Beethoven and other composers in an extremely slow and ponderous , if undeniably majestic manner , in his old age , mainly because of his many health problems . In his earlier years , his performances were said to have been  full of impetuous energy .

   Perhaps  you  could say the the score is the Constitution for the performer ,  but  like  interpretation of the Constitution ,  the  controversies will never end .  But  it would be  terribly boring if every performance  of the same work were identical . Fortunately , there is no likelihood of this ever
happening .
Posted: Nov 23 2011, 06:33 PM by the horn | with no comments
Add to Bloglines Add to Del.icio.us Add to digg Add to Facebook Add to Google Bookmarks Add to Newsvine Add to reddit Add to Stumble Upon Add to Shoutwire Add to Squidoo Add to Technorati Add to Yahoo My Web