By
DANIEL J.
WAKIN
Alan
Gilbert leading the Royal Stockholm Philharmonic during a rehearsal last month.
“He can be a little bit impatient, but that’s because he wants so much,” one
orchestra member said.
ALAN GILBERT stood before the Royal
Stockholm Philharmonic last month in one of the most difficult moments he has
faced as the orchestra’s chief conductor. An hour before, the players learned
that a well-liked former member had committed suicide.
“It feels
strange to rehearse,” Mr. Gilbert quietly told them as they sat on the stage
without instruments, looking stricken. Some held each other. Several sobbed.
“On the other hand, not to rehearse, not to do what we do as musicians, is even
stranger,” Mr. Gilbert added. “It’s a shame that it takes sometimes a terrible
thing like this to remind us that we are a family.”
Responding to
the tragedy was the latest passage for Mr. Gilbert, 40, at the orchestra he has
led for eight years. He literally found family and home there, marrying a section
cellist, Kajsa William-Olsson, fathering two children and buying and renovating
a house. Musically, he learned swaths of repertory and the art of running an
orchestra.
Mr. Gilbert’s
next assignment brings him home to his original clan, the New York Philharmonic, where his mother is a violinist and his father
a retired violinist. He starts there as music director in 2009, one of the few
Americans to take the post and the first native New Yorker. In his next
performance in his hometown, he will conduct the New York Philharmonic for two
weeks in March.
Mr. Gilbert is
a busy guest conductor. But the Royal Stockholm Philharmonic is the only major
orchestra he has directed, and a look at his tenure gives clues to how he will
approach his new job, a high-profile cultural position in a world capital of
classical music.
Even so, the
orchestra in New York is a different kettle of musical fish. Despite the warmth
that exists there between Mr. Gilbert and its members, the skills he acquired
in Sweden won’t always apply.
He took over
the Stockholm orchestra in 2000, a relatively untested 32-year-old put in
charge of a storied orchestra that had slipped in quality. “We thought a young,
eager guy could build something here,” said Mats Engstrom, the artistic
administrator and a former member of the horn section. “I thought he was so
gifted.”
The auspices
were good. Sweden, a country of only nine million people but three fine
orchestras, has long been an incubator for major American conducting careers.
Alumni of the three orchestras — the Goteborg Symphony, the Swedish Radio
Symphony and the Philharmonic — include Esa-Pekka Salonen (now at the Los Angeles Philharmonic), Herbert Blomstedt (formerly at
the San Francisco Symphony), Manfred Honeck (on deck at the
Pittsburgh Symphony), Paavo Jarvi (at the Cincinnati Symphony) and his father,
Neeme Jarvi (at the New Jersey Symphony).
Orchestra staff
members, local officials and music critics say that the bet on Mr. Gilbert has
paid off.
Attendance has
risen from 75 percent of capacity to a healthy 82 percent. Mr. Gilbert has
lobbied politicians and helped the executive director, Stefan Forsberg, gain
extra financing from the regional government, to the chagrin of the orchestra’s
rivals. Mr. Gilbert has helped bring in prominent soloists like Lang Lang, Emanuel Ax and Renée Fleming. From the start, he
programmed Swedish music with enthusiasm, winning over critics and audiences.
Above all, he
has raised the quality of the orchestra, introducing a chamber music aesthetic,
rhythmic precision and a warmer sound, members say. “It’s more locked together
in the sound space,” said Mikael Sjogren, a violist. “It’s real intensity from
the first bar to the last bar.”
Mr. Gilbert, a
violinist, remains popular with the musicians, socializing and playing in
chamber programs with them. A man who projects humility, he seems to have
successfully navigated the sometimes incompatible roles of friend and maestro.
Tellingly, his relationship with Ms. William-Olsson apparently made no waves.
But the
relationship with the orchestra as a whole seems to have run its natural
course. The players have voted to approve a new chief conductor, Sakari Oramo.
It is time for a change, several said.
“Eight years
with Alan was enough,” said Carl Johan Westfelt, a violinist and union
official, who stressed that relations with Mr. Gilbert remained warm. Mr.
Gilbert said he, too, had made it clear that he wanted to leave after this
season. “We all felt it was a good run, and it was right,” he said.
Outside the
orchestra, Mr. Gilbert has maintained a relatively low profile, although
activist conductors in the mold of a Daniel Barenboim in Berlin are not a Swedish tradition. Indeed, except
for the cover of one issue of the orchestra magazine and a small image on a
poster outside the hall, Mr. Gilbert’s face is not seen much. Orchestra officials
say they promote the ensemble and the Concert House, a beautiful neo-Classical
blue box from 1926 facing an outdoor market.
Mr. Gilbert
said he had purposely started his tenure in a low key, in keeping with Sweden’s
consensus-driven nature. “There’s something very Scandinavian about not putting
the individual forward,” he said. “It’s about the team.”
But he asserted
himself in quiet ways. He insisted on having a vote in auditioning new members
and helped force out the previous artistic and executive director, who was seen
by others in the organization as wrong for the job. “Artistically, we needed a
more sharply defined direction,” he said.
Several
musicians took note of an occasional glare over their mistakes. There is
grumbling over his insistence on intense rehearsing, even on the day of a
concert.
“He can be a
little bit impatient, but that’s because he wants so much,” said Ove Ranmo, a
violinist.