The Horn

Contact Me

Receive Email Updates

August 2015 - Posts

The Composer Is Turning In His grave .
  Recently ,  London's Royal Opera , Covent Garden  revived  a legendary , rarely performed opera by  Gioacchino Rossini  (1792 - 1868 ) , best 

known for his beloved comic opera The Barber of Seville .  This was  the famous William Tell , made famous by its use on  "The Lone Ranger ".

    The famous overture is just the opening of a huge , nearly four hour long operatic epic based on  medieval Swiss history , when  Switzerland

was under the tyrannical rule of Austria .  Because of its great length ,  extremely demanding   parts for the principal singers  and overall  

unwieldiness , the opera has never been  performed  frequently , and revivals are always musical events .  

    The opera is chock full of wonderful music  beyond the famous overture , though  ,  so it's definitely worth seeing if you ever get a chance .

It has also frequently been performed with extensive cuts  for practical reasons . 

    But  the recent production in London  provoked  considerable critical outrage  because  the director  , who shall remain nameless ,  

indulged in  some of the typical  directorial mayhem which has been plaguing European  opera productions since the 1970s .   This  dramatic

perversity has been labelled "Eurotrash opera ", or "Regie theater " , in which directors and designers   take truly unwaranted liberties with

dramatic values , such as  adding all manner of gratuitous sex, violence and  ridiculous arbotrary production gimmicks .

     If the  great  composer Rossini were alive today , he would no doubt have suffered heart failure  during one of the opera's ballet  

sequences in this production  .  In one scene , Swiss peasants are dancing in honor of the tyrannical  Austrian ruler of  Switzerland, the one who 

orders  Wiilliam Tell, leader of the Swiss resistance  , to shoot an arrow  in order to attempt to  shoot  an apple off his son's head .

    The director  perversely  turned the ballet into a dance by Austrian soldiers who  strip and brutally rape a young Swss woman !   

He claimed that this was intended to show the  "ugliness of war", or something to that effect .  But was this really necessary  in an opera

like this ? I think not .  The London music critics had a field   day denouncing the director, as well they should have .  But such excesses have 

unfortunately becme the norm in European opera companies, especially Germany , where it's de rigeur to  do all manner of  perverse

things to any given opera .  You almost never see an opera staged in  its original time or even location .  Or possibly it will be  in the

country of the original  libretto , but  it will be in the present day .   Updating the operas is far from the worst part of these productions ,

and is not really objectionable in itself .  But the directors and designers always seem to have some ridiculous  arbitrary gimmick up their

sleeves, just for shock value .  Such as  showing  ***  executing people even in an opera which takes place centuries before the second world 

war ,  and other preposterous gimmicks .  

    There have been  a fair number of productions in America and Canada which update  operas and use gimmicks, but they fortunately tend not 

to be nearly as perverse as the European   ones .

     Interestingly , this production will be  coming to New York's Metropolitan opera in the near future  , where it has not been performed for  

at least 80  or so  years .  Whether the ballet will  repeat  what  was in the London performances remains to be seen ,  but let's hope not !

    The London production  will probably be released on DVD  before long , but there are at least two others  in existence .  Try the production

from La Scala, Milan conducted by Riccardo Muti  , which dates from about 20 or so years ago .   Such a great opera deserves better  than

to be subject  to  gratuitous sex and violence .  Leave poor Rossini in peace, please !

    
Posted: Aug 10 2015, 09:55 PM by the horn | with no comments
Add to Bloglines Add to Del.icio.us Add to digg Add to Facebook Add to Google Bookmarks Add to Newsvine Add to reddit Add to Stumble Upon Add to Shoutwire Add to Squidoo Add to Technorati Add to Yahoo My Web